更新时间:2025-01-20
社会学家如何读文学?——评萨皮罗的《文学社会学》
程心    作者信息&出版信息
Foreign Literature   ·   2025年1月20日   ·   2025年 第1期  
7 0(CNKI)
PDF
该文暂无导航

AI 摘要

Literary sociology is an interdisciplinary field that explores the relationship between literature and society. After the publication of Sapiro's English translation of "Literary Sociology," it received attention from the academic community in Europe and America. The book systematically sorts out the theoretical spectrum and research topics of literary sociology, explores the core essence of literature as a social fact, reveals the bidirectional construction relationship between literature and social reality, and attempts to integrate internal analysis and external criticism. Sapiro proposed a three-dimensional research path centered on the concept of "intermediary": social conditions of literary production, sociology of works, and sociology of reception, emphasizing the interactive relationship between literary creation, textual meaning and reception interpretation, and social context. At the theoretical and methodological level, Sapiro integrates core sociological theoretical resources and introduces empirical research methods such as quantitative analysis to address the dilemma of disciplinary institutionalization in this field. The publication of the English translation of "Sociology of Literature" reflects the significant elevation of the status of sociology of literature in the American academic community, and its methods and perspectives have been deeply embedded in the practice of contemporary English literature research.

At the intersection of literature and sociology

Sapiro regards literature as a social fact in his book "Sociology of Literature", emphasizing the dynamic construction process of the meaning of literary works, in contrast to the Romantic viewpoint. Literary sociology opposes internal criticism and believes that the formation of a work's meaning depends on factors beyond the creator's control, such as the possibility of national or international space and the interactive evolution in cultural fields. Literary sociology regards literature as a social activity, focusing on the interaction between text and society. Its theoretical origins can be traced back to the original sociological analysis theory in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. In the 20th century, literary sociology ushered in new developments, and Marxist criticism and British cultural studies became important theoretical resources. The difficult situation faced by literary sociology reflects the common dilemma of interdisciplinary research, and its true value lies in revealing the social force of literature as a unique cultural form, exploring how literature reflects and intervenes in the construction of social reality. Literary sociology focuses on the multidimensional social existence of literature, viewing it as a dynamic social process that encompasses creation, publication, dissemination, reception, and interpretation, each of which contains complex social interactions and power relations. Sapiro constructed a blueprint for literary sociology, focusing on the intermediary mechanisms between literary works and their social production conditions.

The Three Axes of Literary Sociology

The first axis of literary sociology research shifts the focus from individual writers to the production of literary works, emphasizing that literary creation is a production activity in the social context. Writers draw inspiration from social networks, and their creative practices are influenced by the trends of the times, power relations, and interests. Sapiro proposed that the social conditions for literary production can be divided into two levels: the external world's positioning of literature and the internal operational logic of the literary world. His research path is reflected in the book "The War of French Writers: 1940-1953". The innovative points of studying the social conditions of literary production include focusing on the professional development of writers and the intermediary role of literary institutions.

Intervention from a sociological perspective and its possibilities

The American academic community holds a reserved attitude towards the development prospects of literary sociology, believing that it lacks a solid structure and systematic research agenda. Sapiro's book "Sociology of Literature" aims to respond to this development dilemma by sorting out the academic spectrum of sociology of literature, constructing three research dimensions of literary production, works, and reception, and integrating the research theme of the interaction between literature and society, establishing a basic theoretical framework and research agenda. The book introduces three theoretical schools of thought: functionalism, interactionism, and structuralism, which view the literary world as a relatively autonomous field with their own strengths, providing convenient tools for researchers. However, viewing literature solely as a tool to argue existing theories can lead to the trap of 'literary subordination'. Philsky and Ingrich called for a truly interactive literary sociology, namely a "new and productive encounter between sociology and literary research" that transcends the limitations of critical theory through a "descriptive or practical" approach. Literary sociology also strives to innovate in research methods, introducing many empirical research paths, such as personal career research, interviews, ethnographic investigations, network analysis, and qualitative analysis methods in cartography. Sapiro believes that quantitative methods distinguish literary sociology from traditional literary research and thus highlight its unique theoretical perspective. However, the common dilemma of balancing quantitative and qualitative methods in literary sociology still needs to be resolved. The real challenge facing literary sociology lies not only in methodological innovation, but also in how to redefine the boundaries of literary research and seek a balance between macro synthesis and micro analysis, transforming sociological perspectives into hermeneutic insights.

* 以上内容由AI自动生成,内容仅供参考。对于因使用本网站以上内容产生的相关后果,本网站不承担任何商业和法律责任。

展开

当前期刊

当前期刊
    目录