更新时间:2024-08-10
A Review of Thorsten Wilhelm’s Holocaust Narratives—Trauma, Memory and Identity across Generations
李金云    作者信息&出版信息
Foreign Literature   ·   2024年8月10日   ·   2023年 第6期  
0 0(CNKI)
PDF
该文暂无导航

AI 摘要

The book 'Holocaust Narratives' delves into the narratives of Holocaust survivors and their descendants, analyzing how these narratives construct the collective memory and cultural trauma of Jewish people worldwide. The book selects six novels, including Wessel's "Night" and Begley's "Wartime Lies," representing the narratives of survivors, the second generation, and the third generation, respectively. The author points out that literary attention to the Holocaust after World War II was initially not widespread, until the late 1970s when American Jewish writers began to pay attention to this topic, and since the 1990s, there has been an increase in related research works. The introduction section of the book discusses the impact of Holocaust trauma on different generations and its relationship with collective memory and identity recognition. Chapters one and two focus on the narratives of survivors, emphasizing their authenticity; Chapters three and four analyze the fictional elements in the second generation narrative and explore how they create a sense of reality based on real experiences; Chapters 5 and 6 discuss the fictionality of third-generation narratives and how they imagine and re represent based on the experiences of their ancestors. The conclusion section summarizes the content of the entire book and explores the cultural and sociological significance of the narrative of the Holocaust. Wilhelm's work combines theory and textual analysis to comprehensively outline the development of Holocaust narratives, providing a new perspective for the study of Holocaust literature.

Holocaust trauma, intergenerational trauma, cultural trauma, post memory

The book 'Holocaust Narrative' delves into the profound impact of the Holocaust on survivors and their descendants, including concepts such as psychological trauma, intergenerational trauma, cultural trauma, and post memory. The book quotes Freud's definition, describing trauma as an experience beyond normal adaptation that leads to permanent disruption of the mind. The inhumane treatment of Jews during the Holocaust caused serious psychological trauma, which not only affected the survivors themselves, but also affected their descendants through intergenerational transmission, resulting in emotions such as loss and anxiety. Intergenerational trauma operates unconsciously, haunting future generations like ghosts. Yale sociology professor Erikson proposed the concept of collective trauma, pointing out that the Holocaust destroyed Jewish collective consciousness and religious beliefs. American sociologist Jay Alexander focuses on the representation of trauma and believes that cultural trauma is the result of repeated representations by social elites through media, with government involvement. Post memory is a concept proposed by Hirsch based on the response of survivors' descendants to the Holocaust, emphasizing that the connection between post memory and the past is achieved through imagination rather than recall. In the book, Wilm points out that there are differences in the narratives of the Holocaust among survivors and their second and third generations, with each generation speaking out about their trauma based on their own needs and placing themselves in a connection with their predecessors. The narrative of the Holocaust not only conveys history, but also responsibility, prompting readers to think about how to avoid the tragedy from happening again. Through reading, readers witness and participate in the trauma of the Holocaust, influencing and shaping their cultural memory and identity.

The Witness Narrative of Survivors

The first two chapters of 'Holocaust Narration' delve into Wessel's' Night 'and Begley's' Wartime Lies', exploring the characteristics of survivor Holocaust narratives and their impact on readers. Wiesel's "Night" records the author's terrifying experience in the Auschwitz concentration camp through autobiographical fiction, showcasing the suffering of the Jewish people and the brutality of the Nazis during the Holocaust. Wessel believed that survivors had an obligation to recount the dark years and created a new literary genre called Witness Literature. Night not only witnesses the Holocaust, but also tells the story of a devout Jew who is completely transformed by the trauma of the Holocaust and abandons his faith. Wilhelm delved into the theological significance of the novel, revealing the spiritual destruction of the Jewish people by the Holocaust.

The Second Generation Narrative of Holocaust Trauma

We conducted an in-depth analysis of two novels, "Saving Memories" by Su Che and "Secondhand Smoke" by Rosenbaum, exploring the psychological trauma and intergenerational impact endured by the second generation of Holocaust survivors. The novel showcases how Rachel and Duncan, influenced by their parents, lived in the shadow of the Holocaust, experiencing identity struggles and psychological barriers. Wilm's research suggests that the second generation is not concerned with the Holocaust itself, but rather with the ongoing impact of the Holocaust after the end of the war. Rachel achieves self confirmation through filming and begins to reconcile with the past; And Duncan, with the help of his brother Isaac, worked hard to overcome the trauma and reduce the past to a part of his life. Both works emphasize the importance of inheriting memories of the Holocaust and individuals seeking self redemption within it.

The Third Generation Narrative of Holocaust Trauma

We conducted an in-depth analysis of two works, "The Coming World" by Hahn and "Everything Illuminates," exploring how the third generation of the Holocaust traced the history of their ancestors and integrated it into their own lives. Vilm's research emphasizes the innovation of third-generation narratives, no longer focusing on the trauma of the Holocaust on future generations, but on how they inherit the experiences of their predecessors, establish connections with their ancestors, and construct their own identities. The Coming World "showcases how Benjamin and Sarah strive to establish connections with Jewish culture, history, and language through their stories, in order to confirm their Jewish identity and use writing as a bridge connecting the past, present, and future. In 'Everything is Illuminated', Jonathan's journey to find his roots reveals the concepts of collective memory and cultural trauma, as well as the role of imagination and fiction in filling the gaps between factual fragments when personal memory is broken. In his conclusion, Wilhelm pointed out the promoting role of Holocaust narratives in Jewish identity and their importance as cultural memory and trauma for all humanity. Although Wilm's research has shortcomings in the analysis of narrative techniques, his exploration of the historical context of the Holocaust narrative and its impact on readers provides a solid foundation for subsequent research.

* 以上内容由AI自动生成,内容仅供参考。对于因使用本网站以上内容产生的相关后果,本网站不承担任何商业和法律责任。

展开

当前期刊

当前期刊
    目录

    推荐论文

    • Title: The Ontological Significance of Cultural Memory in Ulysses

    • Perception, Memory, and Phenomenology of London: A Study of Dickens’s Urban Space Narrative

    • Space, Memory and Identity—The Living Predicament in When We Were Orphans